Radial vs rotary: two different “round” engines
Early and mid-20th-century aircraft engines often had their cylinders arranged in a circle. Two quite different designs looked similar from the outside:
| Radial engine | Rotary engine (rotating cylinder) | Wankel rotary | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What spins | The crankshaft | The whole cylinder block and crankcase | A triangular rotor |
| What stays still | Cylinders and crankcase | The crankshaft | The housing |
| Propeller attached to | The crankshaft (sometimes via gearing) | The spinning crankcase | Not used in this sense |
| Main era | 1910s to 1950s, still used in some aircraft | Roughly 1908 to the end of WWI | 1960s onward |
The Wankel shares the name “rotary” but is unrelated. It is covered in our article on how Wankel rotary engines work. This article focuses on radials and the rotating-cylinder rotary.
How a radial engine works
A radial engine is a four-stroke piston engine with its cylinders arranged around a central crankcase like the spokes of a wheel. Each cylinder goes through the usual intake, compression, power and exhaust strokes, and all the pistons push inward on a single crankshaft at the centre.
Master rod and articulating rods
In a single row of cylinders, all the pistons sit in the same plane, so their connecting rods cannot each have their own crankpin side by side as they would in an inline engine. Radials solve this with a two-part rod system:
- Master rod. One cylinder’s connecting rod is attached directly to the single crankpin. Its big end is a large hub.
- Articulating rods. The connecting rods from every other cylinder attach to pins arranged around the master rod’s hub.
As the pistons are driven inward on their power strokes, the whole assembly of master rod and articulating rods sweeps around the crankpin and turns the crankshaft. Because the articulating rods pivot on the master rod rather than on the crank itself, their geometry is slightly different from the master cylinder’s, and engineers allow for this in the design.
Why radials use an odd number of cylinders
Nearly every four-stroke radial has an odd number of cylinders in each row: five, seven or nine are typical.
The reason is the firing order. A four-stroke cylinder fires once every two crankshaft revolutions. A radial fires every other cylinder as the crank goes around, so that each cylinder gets its turn over two revolutions with evenly spaced power pulses:
- Five cylinders: 1-3-5-2-4
- Seven cylinders: 1-3-5-7-2-4-6
- Nine cylinders: 1-3-5-7-9-2-4-6-8
With an odd count, skipping every other cylinder works its way through all of them before repeating. With an even count, the pattern would fire only the odd-numbered cylinders on one lap and only the even-numbered ones on the next, which does not give an even, regular sequence. This is one of the main reasons seven-cylinder engines, which are almost unknown in cars, were common in aircraft. See our answer to whether a 7-cylinder engine exists.
How the valves are operated
Most radials have poppet valves in each cylinder head, opened by pushrods and rocker arms. Instead of a camshaft running along the engine, a radial typically uses a cam ring or cam plate: a ring with lobes on it, geared to turn slowly around the crankshaft. As it turns, its lobes push the cam followers and pushrods for each cylinder in turn.
Multi-row radials
To get more power without making the engine wider, designers stacked rows of cylinders one behind the other on the same crankshaft, with the rear row offset so its cylinders sit in the gaps and catch cooling air. Well-known examples include:
- 14-cylinder two-row radials, such as the Pratt & Whitney R-1830 Twin Wasp
- 18-cylinder two-row radials, such as the Pratt & Whitney R-2800 Double Wasp and the Wright R-3350
- The 28-cylinder Pratt & Whitney R-4360 Wasp Major, with four rows of seven cylinders
Why radials suited aircraft
- Air cooling. Every cylinder head faces the oncoming airflow, so radials could be air-cooled without the weight and vulnerability of a liquid cooling system.
- Short length. The engine is compact front to back, which suits the nose of an aircraft.
- Good power-to-weight ratio for the technology of the time, helped by the short, stiff crankshaft.
- Simplicity of maintenance, with each cylinder accessible around the outside.
Disadvantages of radial engines
- Large frontal area. The round engine creates drag. Cowlings were developed to reduce drag and guide cooling air, but liquid-cooled inline and V engines could be given more streamlined noses.
- Cooling rear rows. In multi-row engines, the rear cylinders get less direct airflow and need baffles to stay cool.
- Oil in the lower cylinders. When the engine is stopped, oil can drain past the piston rings into the lower cylinders and intake pipes. This causes smoke at start-up and, in the worst case, hydraulic lock (see below).
- Oil consumption and leaks. Radials are known for using and leaking more oil than many modern aircraft engines.
- Size limits. As aircraft needed more power, radials grew more complex, and gas turbines eventually replaced them in most high-power roles. Our article on how gas turbine engines work covers what came next.
Why radial engines are hard to start
Radials have a reputation for being fussy starters. Common reasons include:
- Hydraulic lock risk. Oil that has drained into a lower cylinder cannot be compressed. If the engine is turned with the starter while a cylinder is full of oil, the piston can be stopped abruptly, which can bend a connecting rod or cause other serious damage. For this reason, crews typically pull the propeller through by hand for several blades before starting, to check that it turns freely. If it does not, the oil has to be drained before the engine is started.
- Priming. Cold radials often need careful priming with fuel to start, and too much or too little makes starting harder.
- Size and inertia. Large radials have a lot of rotating mass to get moving. Historically, some used inertia starters or cartridge starters.
- Smoke and rough running. Oil burned off from the lower cylinders makes the first seconds smoky and uneven.
Procedures differ between engines and aircraft, so anyone operating a radial should follow the specific manufacturer’s and operator’s procedures.
How rotating-cylinder rotary engines worked
The rotary engine, in its aircraft sense, turned the radial inside out. The crankshaft was bolted firmly to the aircraft. The crankcase and the ring of cylinders, with the propeller attached to them, spun around it. Famous examples include the French Gnome and Le Rhône engines and the Clerget, which powered the Sopwith Camel among other aircraft.
Like radials, rotaries generally had odd numbers of cylinders per row, seven and nine being common, for the same firing-order reason.
Fuel and oil through a hollow crankshaft
Because the crankshaft did not move, it could be used as a pipe. The fuel-air mixture was fed through the hollow crankshaft into the crankcase and from there into the cylinders. Many rotaries used castor oil, which did not mix readily with the fuel, and a total-loss lubrication system in which the oil passed through the engine once and was thrown out with the exhaust rather than recirculated. That meant high oil consumption and pilots covered in oil mist.
Controlling power
Some rotaries had limited ability to throttle the engine smoothly. Pilots of some types used a “blip switch” to cut the ignition briefly and reduce power, for example when landing.
Gyroscopic effects
A spinning mass of cylinders and propeller acts like a large gyroscope. When the aircraft pitched or yawed, gyroscopic precession pushed it in another direction. Combined with the engine’s torque, this gave some rotary-powered fighters, the Sopwith Camel being the classic example, a tendency to turn much more quickly one way than the other. Skilled pilots could use this in combat, but it made the aircraft demanding to fly.
Why rotary aircraft engines disappeared
Rotaries were light for their power and cooled themselves by spinning through the air, which made them attractive in the early years of aviation. Their drawbacks grew as more power was needed:
- Drag on the spinning cylinders. Spinning a ring of cylinders through the air absorbs power, and the loss grows quickly with engine size and speed.
- Mechanical stress. Large spinning cylinders are subject to heavy centrifugal loads.
- Fuel and oil consumption. The total-loss oiling and limited throttle control were wasteful.
- Handling. Gyroscopic effects increased with heavier engines.
By around the end of the First World War, stationary radials and liquid-cooled inline and V engines could deliver more power more efficiently, and the rotating-cylinder rotary faded out.
Radial and rotary questions
Do radial engines rotate?
The cylinders of a radial engine do not rotate. They are fixed to the crankcase, which is bolted to the aircraft, and only the crankshaft and propeller turn. The engines whose cylinders spin around a fixed crankshaft are the rotary engines described above. The two are easy to confuse because they look similar when stopped.
How many cylinders does a rotary engine have?
A rotating-cylinder aircraft rotary usually had seven or nine cylinders in a single row, and some larger versions used two rows. A Wankel rotary has no cylinders at all; instead it is described by its number of rotors, most commonly two.
Can you put a radial engine in a car?
It has been done. Radial engines were used in some Second World War armoured vehicles, including versions of the American M3 Stuart and M4 Sherman tanks, and enthusiasts have built custom cars and trucks around radial engines. They are not practical for everyday cars: they are wide, have a large round shape that is hard to package, are designed to run at relatively steady speeds with a propeller as the load, and depend on strong airflow for air cooling.
How is this different from a Wankel rotary?
A Wankel has no pistons or cylinders. A three-sided rotor turns inside a specially shaped housing and drives an eccentric shaft. The aircraft rotary is a conventional piston engine whose whole cylinder block spins. Read more in our guide to Wankel rotary engines, or see our overview of engine types for how all these designs compare.