Engine Types

How Boxer (Flat) Engines Work and Why Subaru and Porsche Use Them

How a boxer engine works, why opposed pistons cancel vibration and lower the center of gravity, its trade-offs, and why Subaru and Porsche still use it.

On this page
  1. What a boxer engine is
  2. How a boxer engine works
  3. Boxer vs 180-degree V engines
  4. How well balanced is a boxer?
  5. Advantages of boxer engines
  6. Drawbacks of boxer engines
  7. Why Subaru uses boxer engines
  8. Why Porsche uses flat engines
  9. Other boxer engines
  10. Living with a boxer engine

What a boxer engine is

A boxer engine is a piston engine whose cylinders lie flat, in two banks on opposite sides of the crankshaft. Viewed from the front, the two banks point directly away from each other at 180 degrees. It is also called a horizontally opposed or flat engine.

The name comes from the way the pistons move. Each piston has a partner directly opposite it, and the pair move outward and inward at the same time, like a boxer’s fists punching out and pulling back. Subaru has used boxer engines in almost all of its combustion-engined cars for decades, and Porsche’s 911 has been powered by a flat-six since the 1960s.

For how the boxer fits among other layouts, see our guide to the types of car engines.

How a boxer engine works

Each cylinder in a boxer runs the same four-stroke cycle as any other piston engine: intake, compression, power and exhaust. What is different is the geometry:

  • Two cylinder banks, lying flat. A flat-four has two cylinders on each side; a flat-six has three.
  • One crankshaft in the middle. Both banks drive the same crankshaft, which sits low in the centre of the engine.
  • Each piston has its own crankpin. In a true boxer, opposing pistons attach to crankpins on opposite sides of the crankshaft, 180 degrees apart. As the crank turns, both pistons are pushed out to the ends of their cylinders at the same moment and pulled back in together.
  • Two cylinder heads. Each bank has its own head, valves and camshafts, one on each side of the engine.

Because opposing pistons always move in opposite directions, the force of one pushing left is matched by the other pushing right. That mirror-image motion is the key to the boxer’s smoothness.

Boxer vs 180-degree V engines

Not every flat engine is a true boxer. A 180-degree V engine also has its cylinders lying flat on opposite sides, but opposing pistons share a single crankpin, as they do in an ordinary V engine. Instead of moving in and out together, one piston moves toward the crankshaft while its partner moves away, so they travel in the same direction.

The difference matters for balance, and it can lead to confusion over names. Ferrari’s famous “Berlinetta Boxer” models, for example, used a flat-12 that is often described technically as a 180-degree V12 rather than a true boxer. Subaru and Porsche flat engines are true boxers.

How well balanced is a boxer?

  • Flat-four. The main up-and-down forces from opposing pistons cancel well, so a flat-four is smoother than an inline-four, which has an inherent shake at twice engine speed. However, the two cylinders in each opposing pair cannot sit exactly opposite each other, because their connecting rods sit side by side along the crankshaft. That slight offset leaves a small rocking motion. It is modest and well controlled by engine mounts.
  • Flat-six. A flat-six is essentially two flat-threes back to back, and like an inline-6 it is considered essentially fully balanced. That is part of why Porsche’s flat-sixes are known for their smoothness. The inline-6 guide explains the same principle for the straight-six.

Advantages of boxer engines

  • Low centre of gravity. A flat engine sits low in the car, with its heaviest parts close to the ground. This can reduce body roll and help handling.
  • Smooth running. Opposed pistons cancel much of each other’s vibration, often without the balance shafts an inline-four would need.
  • Short length. A flat-four is much shorter than an inline-four, which helps with packaging, particularly in a longitudinal layout.
  • Good for longitudinal all-wheel drive. A short, low engine mounted lengthwise can sit in line with the transmission and drive both axles with a fairly symmetrical layout.
  • Possible crash benefit. Subaru says that in a severe frontal collision, its low-mounted engine is designed to move downward beneath the passenger compartment rather than into it. How much this contributes compared with the rest of a car’s crash structure is hard to separate.

Drawbacks of boxer engines

  • Width. The cylinders stick out sideways, making the engine wide. That can crowd the engine bay and limit steering angle or suspension design in some cars.
  • More parts. Two cylinder heads mean two sets of camshafts, two valve covers and two head gaskets. A double-overhead-camshaft flat-four has four camshafts, compared with two in an inline-four.
  • Maintenance access. Spark plugs and some other parts sit low on the sides of the engine, close to the chassis rails, which can make jobs fiddlier than on an inline engine.
  • Exhaust layout. Exhaust ports on both sides must be joined, which complicates the exhaust system and the placement of turbochargers.
  • Oil and start-up smoke. With horizontal cylinders, a small amount of oil can seep past the piston rings while the engine sits, sometimes causing a brief puff of smoke at start-up. Occasional brief smoke is not necessarily a fault, but persistent smoke should be checked.

Why Subaru uses boxer engines

Subaru built its first boxer-engined car, the Subaru 1000, in 1966, and has stayed with the layout ever since. Several reasons have kept it there:

  • Symmetrical all-wheel drive. Subaru mounts its boxer engines lengthwise with the transmission directly behind, which allows a balanced, left-right symmetrical drivetrain feeding both axles. A short flat engine suits this arrangement well.
  • Handling and stability. The low centre of gravity supports Subaru’s emphasis on stability in poor weather and on rough roads.
  • Engineering investment. After decades of developing boxer engines, the tooling, expertise and parts are well established, and the engine has become part of the brand’s identity.

Subaru’s boxer engines have not been trouble-free. Some older engines from its EJ family, particularly certain 2.5-litre versions, gained a reputation for head gasket problems. Like any engine, reliability varies by generation and depends a great deal on maintenance.

Why Porsche uses flat engines

Porsche has used flat engines since its earliest cars, which drew on Volkswagen Beetle engineering. The 911, launched in the 1960s, has always used a flat-six mounted behind the rear axle.

  • Low, compact rear mounting. A flat engine sits low and short, which matters when it is hung behind the rear wheels.
  • Smoothness and character. The flat-six’s balance and distinctive sound are central to the 911’s identity.
  • Tradition. Porsche has kept the layout through the change from air cooling to water cooling and the adoption of turbocharging.

Porsche’s mid-engined Boxster and Cayman models have used both flat-sixes and, in some generations, turbocharged flat-fours.

Other boxer engines

Boxers have appeared in many places beyond Subaru and Porsche:

  • Volkswagen Beetle, with its air-cooled rear-mounted flat-four
  • Citroën 2CV, with a small air-cooled flat-twin
  • Chevrolet Corvair, with an air-cooled flat-six
  • Toyota GR86 and Subaru BRZ, sports cars using a Subaru flat-four
  • BMW motorcycles, many of which use a flat-twin with cylinders sticking out to each side
  • Honda Gold Wing touring motorcycles, which have used flat-fours and flat-sixes
  • Light aircraft, where horizontally opposed four- and six-cylinder engines from makers such as Lycoming and Continental are very common

Living with a boxer engine

If you own or are thinking of buying a boxer-engined car, a few points are worth knowing:

  • Check the oil regularly. Some boxer engines have been known to use a little oil between changes. Follow the manufacturer’s recommendations for checking and topping up.
  • Expect some jobs to cost more. Spark plug and head gasket work can take longer on a flat engine than on an inline engine.
  • Research the specific engine. Reliability differs between engine generations, so look up the record of the particular engine in the car you are considering.
  • Follow the service schedule, including timing belt replacement on engines that use a belt rather than a chain.

For another engine layout where the crankshaft design shapes the whole character of the engine, see our article on flat-plane vs cross-plane crank V8s.

The complete guide to engine types

Types of Car Engines: Layouts, Cylinder Arrangements and Placement
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →