Engine Types

Flat-Plane vs Cross-Plane Crank V8s: Sound, Balance and Power

Flat-plane vs cross-plane V8 cranks explained: how crankpin angle changes firing order, balance, exhaust tuning and sound, and which cars use each design.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What “plane” means on a crankshaft
  3. Firing order: where the sound comes from
  4. Balance and vibration
  5. Exhaust tuning and breathing
  6. Revving and power
  7. Flat-plane vs cross-plane at a glance
  8. Which cars use each type
  9. Why most V8s are still cross-plane
  10. Crossplane beyond V8s

The short answer

A cross-plane V8 crankshaft has its four crankpins spaced 90 degrees apart, so seen end-on they form a cross. A flat-plane crankshaft has them 180 degrees apart, all lying in a single flat plane.

That one difference changes a lot. Cross-plane V8s are very smooth, with the deep, uneven burble most people think of as the V8 sound, but they need heavy counterweights. Flat-plane V8s are lighter and rev more freely, breathe more efficiently at high revs, and have a higher-pitched, smoother-sounding exhaust note, but they vibrate more. Most American and many European V8s are cross-plane; Ferrari, McLaren and a few high-revving performance engines use flat-plane cranks.

What “plane” means on a crankshaft

A V8 has four crankpins, each shared by two connecting rods, one from each bank. How those crankpins are arranged around the crankshaft is what “plane” refers to.

  • Flat-plane (180-degree) crank. The crankpins point alternately up and down. Looking along the crankshaft, they all lie in one flat plane. Each bank of four cylinders behaves like an inline-four engine.
  • Cross-plane (90-degree) crank. Each crankpin is turned 90 degrees from the next. Looking along the crankshaft, they form a plus sign or cross, using two planes at right angles.

Early V8s in the 1910s used flat-plane cranks, which were simpler to make. Cross-plane cranks were introduced in the 1920s to cure the vibration, and they became the standard for most V8s that followed.

Firing order: where the sound comes from

Both designs fire all eight cylinders evenly overall, one every 90 degrees of crankshaft rotation. The difference is in how those firings are shared between the two banks.

Cross-plane: uneven firing in each bank

With a cross-plane crank, the firing order jumps between banks in an irregular pattern. At some points, two cylinders on the same bank fire one after the other; at others, the firing alternates. If you could listen to just one bank’s exhaust, you would hear pulses arriving at uneven intervals.

When each bank’s exhaust is collected separately, as it usually is in road cars, those uneven pulses give the cross-plane V8 its loping, burbling rumble, especially at idle and low revs. It is the sound of classic American muscle cars and pickups.

Flat-plane: even firing, alternating banks

With a flat-plane crank, the firing alternates neatly from one bank to the other: left, right, left, right. Each bank fires every 180 degrees, exactly like an inline-four.

Each bank’s exhaust pulses are therefore evenly spaced, and the combined sound is smoother and higher-pitched, often described as a wail or scream at high revs. It sounds more like two four-cylinder engines working together than a traditional V8.

Balance and vibration

Cross-plane V8s can be very well balanced. With suitable counterweights on the crankshaft, the main shaking forces and rocking motions can be cancelled, leaving a smooth engine. The catch is that those counterweights are heavy, which adds rotating mass.

Flat-plane V8s inherit the balance characteristics of an inline-four. The main forces cancel and the crankshaft needs only small counterweights, but there is a secondary shaking force at twice engine speed that does not cancel out. In a V8 with banks at 90 degrees, this shows up as a side-to-side vibration. It is manageable with engine mounts, and less of an issue in high-performance cars where some vibration is accepted, but it is one reason flat-plane V8s have mostly stayed in sports and racing cars.

For comparison, our guide to inline-6 engines explains a layout that is balanced without any counterweight tricks, and our article on boxer engines covers another way of cancelling vibration.

Exhaust tuning and breathing

Exhaust pulses can be used to help pull spent gas out of the next cylinder, an effect known as scavenging. It works best when pulses arrive at evenly spaced intervals.

  • Flat-plane: each bank fires evenly, so a simple four-into-one header on each bank can be tuned for good scavenging. The engine breathes efficiently at high revs.
  • Cross-plane: each bank fires unevenly, so getting the same effect requires exhaust headers that cross over between the banks, pairing cylinders from both sides so the pulses in each collector are evenly spaced. Racing cars like the Ford GT40 used intricate crossover exhausts, nicknamed a “bundle of snakes,” for exactly this reason. In most road cars, the packaging cost is too high, and the uneven pulses are simply accepted, with the burble as a side effect.

Revving and power

Because a flat-plane crankshaft needs much smaller counterweights, it is lighter and has less rotating inertia. Combined with its more efficient high-rpm breathing, that makes flat-plane V8s well suited to very high engine speeds and quick throttle response. Many flat-plane road car V8s rev well past the speeds typical of cross-plane production V8s.

It is often said that cross-plane V8s make more low-end torque. That is more about how the engines are usually designed and tuned than about the crank itself. Cross-plane V8s in trucks and muscle cars are typically built with large displacement and tuned for low- and mid-range torque, while flat-plane engines are typically built to rev. Both crank types can be tuned in different directions.

Flat-plane vs cross-plane at a glance

Flat-plane crank Cross-plane crank
Crankpin spacing 180 degrees, one plane 90 degrees, two planes
Bank firing Evenly alternates left-right Uneven within each bank
Typical sound High-pitched, smooth wail Deep, uneven burble
Counterweights Small, light crank Heavy counterweights
Vibration Secondary vibration remains Very smooth when properly balanced
Exhaust Simple per-bank headers scavenge well Needs crossover headers for best scavenging
Typical use Exotic and high-revving performance cars, racing Most production V8s, trucks, muscle and luxury cars

Which cars use each type

Flat-plane V8s:

  • Most Ferrari V8 road cars
  • McLaren’s twin-turbo V8s
  • The 5.2-litre V8 in the Ford Mustang Shelby GT350
  • The 5.5-litre V8 in the C8 Chevrolet Corvette Z06
  • Many racing V8s

Cross-plane V8s:

  • GM’s small-block V8s in Corvettes, Camaros, Silverados and others
  • Ford’s Coyote V8 in the regular Mustang GT and F-150
  • Stellantis Hemi V8s
  • Most V8s from Mercedes-AMG, BMW, Audi, Toyota and Lexus

Why most V8s are still cross-plane

For a road car, smoothness and refinement usually matter more than the last few hundred rpm. A cross-plane V8 can be made very smooth, needs less work on engine mounts, and offers the familiar V8 sound buyers often want. It also suits large-displacement engines tuned for torque in trucks and everyday cars. Flat-plane cranks make the most sense where high revs, sharp response and racing-style exhaust tuning are the priority and some extra vibration is acceptable.

Crossplane beyond V8s

The “crossplane” idea has also been used outside V8s. Yamaha’s YZF-R1 motorcycle, for example, has used a crossplane crankshaft in an inline-four since the late 2000s, giving it an uneven firing order and a distinctive sound, with the aim of making its power delivery feel more predictable to the rider.

Crankshaft and bank layout choices shape other multi-cylinder engines too. Volkswagen’s W engines, for instance, combine narrow-angle banks in unusual ways, as our explainer on W8, W12 and W16 engines shows. For a broader overview, see our guide to the types of car engines.

The complete guide to engine types

Types of Car Engines: Layouts, Cylinder Arrangements and Placement
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →