The Subaru BRZ’s engines are generally reliable for street driving, but each generation has known issues. The first-generation FA20 (2013–2020) had a valve spring recall on early cars, a harmless but annoying fuel pump “cricket” noise and a well-known torque dip. The second-generation FA24 (2022 onward) has drawn attention for oil starvation and bearing failures, mostly on cars driven hard on track.
Here’s what goes wrong with each engine, why, and how to keep one healthy.
Which Engine Does Your BRZ Have?
The BRZ was co-developed with Toyota (sold as the Scion FR-S, Toyota 86 and GR86), and both generations use a Subaru horizontally opposed (“boxer”) four-cylinder with Toyota’s D-4S fuel system, which combines port and direct injection.
| First generation | Second generation | |
|---|---|---|
| Model years | 2013–2020 | 2022 onward |
| Engine | FA20 (2.0 liters) | FA24 (2.4 liters) |
| Output | About 200 hp (205 hp on later manual cars) | About 228 hp |
| Induction | Naturally aspirated | Naturally aspirated |
Note that the BRZ’s FA20 is not the same engine as the turbocharged FA20 used in the WRX and Forester XT. They share a family name but differ in fuel system, internals and tuning.
First-Generation FA20 Problems
Valve Spring Recall
Certain early FA20 cars (and their Toyota and Scion twins) were recalled for valve springs that could fracture, which could cause abnormal engine noise, rough running, or the engine stalling while driving. The fix was replacing the valve springs. If you’re buying an early first-generation BRZ, check by VIN that the recall work is done.
Fuel Pump “Cricket” Noise
Many FA20 owners notice a chirping or ticking sound at idle, often compared to crickets. It’s generally attributed to the high-pressure fuel pump and injectors of the direct-injection system, and is widely considered harmless. It’s worth knowing about so you don’t mistake it for a valvetrain problem.
Torque Dip
The FA20 has a noticeable dip in torque around the middle of the rev range, roughly 3,500–4,500 rpm, which makes acceleration feel flat there. It’s a characteristic of the engine’s tuning and intake/exhaust design, not a fault. Many owners address it with aftermarket headers and a tune. Be aware that modifications can affect emissions compliance and warranty coverage.
Oil Leaks and Consumption
Higher-mileage FA20 engines can develop oil leaks, such as from camshaft seals or the timing cover, and some oil consumption. Neither is unusual for an engine of its age, but check under the car and ask about oil top-ups.
Valvetrain Wear
There are owner reports of rocker arm and valvetrain problems, often after over-revving (such as a missed downshift) or high-mileage wear. They’re not widespread on street cars, but a used FA20 that has been tracked or over-revved deserves a careful listen for valvetrain noise.
Second-Generation FA24 Problems
Oil Starvation on Track
The most discussed FA24 issue is oil starvation during long, hard cornering, especially sustained high-g turns at high rpm on a racetrack. Oil can be pushed away from the pickup, oil pressure drops briefly, and connecting rod bearings can be damaged. Several FA24 failures have been reported, mostly on track or autocross cars. The issue has been the subject of owner complaints and at least one proposed class action.
RTV Sealant and Oil Pickup Concerns
Some owners and shops have reported finding excess factory RTV sealant (a silicone gasket maker) that had broken loose and partly blocked the oil pickup screen. Opinion is divided on how often this causes failures by itself versus adding to oil-starvation problems on track. It’s something to raise if you ever have the oil pan off.
Low-Speed Pre-Ignition and Drivability
Like many modern direct-injection engines, the FA24 can be sensitive to low-speed pre-ignition (LSPI), an abnormal combustion event that can happen under heavy throttle at low rpm. Using oil that meets the manufacturer’s current specification (modern API SP oils are formulated to resist LSPI) and avoiding lugging the engine in a high gear both help. Some owners also report rough idle or hesitation, which may be addressed by software updates.
Why Boxer Engines Are Sensitive to Oil Slosh
A boxer engine lays its cylinders flat on either side of the crankshaft. That gives a low center of gravity, which is one reason the BRZ handles so well, but it also means:
- The oil pan is wide and shallow, so oil can slosh away from the pickup under sustained cornering force.
- Oil has to drain back from two cylinder heads on opposite sides of the engine, and under high g-loads it can pool in one head instead of returning to the sump.
Street driving rarely produces those loads for long enough to matter. Track driving can. That’s why track-focused owners often add a baffled oil pan, an oil cooler and an oil pressure or temperature gauge, and keep the oil exactly at the full mark.
Is the Subaru 2.0 Boxer Reliable?
For the BRZ’s FA20, generally yes. On street-driven cars with regular oil changes, the FA20 has a good reputation, and the early valve spring recall addressed its most serious defect. Many owners report trouble-free use well into high mileage.
Note that “Subaru boxer” covers a lot of engines. Older Subaru EJ25 engines (not used in the BRZ) are known for head gasket problems, which is one reason some buyers are wary. The FA-series engines in the BRZ are a newer design. For a broader look at engines with genuinely poor records, see the least reliable engines of all time.
Why Isn’t the BRZ Turbocharged?
Subaru and Toyota designed the BRZ and its twins around light weight, low cost, a low center of gravity and predictable handling, rather than raw power. A turbocharger adds weight, heat, cost and complexity, and it changes how the engine responds to the throttle. The engineers prioritized a naturally aspirated engine with sharp, linear response and kept the car affordable. The second generation addressed complaints about power by increasing displacement to 2.4 liters rather than adding a turbo. Aftermarket turbo and supercharger kits do exist, but they add stress to an engine that wasn’t designed for boost.
How to Keep a BRZ Engine Healthy
- Change the oil on time with the viscosity and specification in the owner’s manual. Shorten the interval if you track the car.
- Check the oil level regularly, and keep it at the full mark rather than near the minimum.
- Warm the engine up before using high rpm.
- Avoid lugging the engine at very low rpm in high gears.
- For track use, consider a baffled oil pan, an oil cooler and oil pressure/temperature monitoring, and consult a specialist familiar with the platform.
- Keep software up to date at the dealer.
Buying a Used BRZ
- Check recall status by VIN, especially the valve spring recall on early FA20 cars and any later campaigns on FA24 cars.
- Ask about track history. Lots of track days raise the risk of bearing wear, especially on the FA24.
- Listen at cold start and idle. Learn the normal fuel pump “cricket” sound so you can spot anything louder or more mechanical.
- Look for oil leaks and ask how often the oil has needed topping up.
- Ask about modifications. Tunes and headers are common and not necessarily bad, but they should be done properly.
The BRZ shares its development with Toyota. For Toyota’s own problem engines, see which Toyota engine to stay away from.