Timing and Valvetrain

What happens if valve timing is incorrect?

What incorrect valve timing does to an engine, from rough running and lost power to bent valves, plus the symptoms, common causes and what to do next.

On this page
  1. Why valve timing has to be exact
  2. What happens depends on how far off it is
  3. Advanced vs retarded cam timing
  4. Symptoms of incorrect valve timing
  5. Common causes
  6. How mechanics confirm a valve timing problem
  7. What to do if you suspect it
  8. Can incorrect valve timing be fixed?

If valve timing is incorrect, the valves open and close at the wrong points in the piston’s travel. The engine loses its ability to breathe and compress properly, so it usually runs roughly, makes less power, starts poorly and may set a check engine light. How serious it is depends on how far off the timing is and how the engine is designed.

A small error, such as a belt or chain one tooth out, often just causes poor running. A large error, or a complete loss of timing from a broken belt or chain, can let the pistons hit open valves in an interference engine, bending valves and sometimes damaging pistons and the cylinder head. In a non-interference engine, the engine usually just stops or won’t run, without that internal damage.

Why valve timing has to be exact

In a four-stroke engine, the camshaft opens the intake and exhaust valves once every two crankshaft revolutions. The crankshaft and camshaft are linked by a timing belt, chain or gears so each valve opens and closes at a specific crankshaft angle. Our engine timing guide explains this relationship in more detail.

Those angles are chosen carefully. The intake valve has to close at the right moment to trap the mixture for compression. The exhaust valve has to open at the right moment to release pressure after the power stroke. And around top dead center, the small window when both are open (overlap) has to be timed so the exhaust leaves and the fresh charge comes in without mixing badly. If the camshaft is rotated away from where it should be, all of these events move together, and the engine stops working the way it was designed to.

What happens depends on how far off it is

Slightly off (one tooth)

One tooth on a typical timing sprocket represents several degrees of crankshaft rotation; the exact figure depends on the number of teeth. One tooth out often produces:

  • Noticeably reduced power, especially at one end of the rev range
  • Rough or unstable idle
  • Harder starting
  • Poor fuel economy
  • A check engine light, often with crankshaft/camshaft correlation codes

Some engines run surprisingly well one tooth out, which can hide the problem. On an interference engine, even this can reduce the safety margin between valves and pistons, so it shouldn’t be ignored.

Badly off (several teeth)

With several teeth of error, the engine may barely run or not run at all. Compression drops because valves are open when they should be closed. You may hear popping back through the intake or exhaust. On an interference engine, a large error can let a valve and piston touch, even if the belt or chain is still intact.

Timing lost completely

If the belt or chain breaks, or strips enough teeth that the camshaft stops turning with the crankshaft, the valves stop moving in step with the pistons. The engine stops running immediately.

  • In an interference engine, the pistons can strike any valves that were left open. Bent valves are the most common result, and damage to pistons, valve guides, camshafts or the cylinder head is possible.
  • In a non-interference engine, there’s clearance for the pistons even with valves fully open, so the usual repair is a new belt or chain and associated parts, followed by checks.

Our article on interference vs non-interference engines explains how to find out which kind you have and what the repair options are.

Advanced vs retarded cam timing

When the camshaft is ahead of where it should be, the cam timing is advanced; when it’s behind, it’s retarded. Engine builders sometimes move a camshaft a few degrees deliberately to tune it, and variable valve timing systems do this constantly. But a jumped tooth moves it far more than intended.

In general terms:

  • Advanced cam timing makes the intake valve close earlier, which tends to favor low-RPM torque at the expense of high-RPM power.
  • Retarded cam timing makes it close later, which tends to favor high-RPM breathing at the expense of low-speed torque and cranking compression.

These effects are useful in small amounts. Beyond that, both directions mostly make the engine run badly. For more on how cam timing interacts with overlap, see valve overlap and exhaust reversion explained.

Symptoms of incorrect valve timing

Common signs include:

  • Check engine light, often with codes such as P0016 to P0019 on OBD-II vehicles (crankshaft/camshaft position correlation) or cam timing “over-advanced” or “over-retarded” codes
  • Rough idle, misfires or stalling
  • Loss of power and poor acceleration
  • Hard starting, or cranking without starting
  • Popping or backfiring through the intake or exhaust
  • Rattling from the front of the engine, if a worn chain or tensioner is the cause
  • Low or uneven compression readings

Many of these overlap with ignition, fuel and vacuum problems, so they suggest a timing fault rather than prove one.

Common causes

Jumped or worn belt or chain

A belt with worn or missing teeth can slip relative to the sprocket. A timing chain that has worn (often described as “stretched”) becomes effectively longer, which shifts cam timing and can eventually let it jump a tooth. See what a timing chain does for an engine for what that wear actually is.

Tensioner or guide failure

The tensioner keeps the belt or chain tight. If it weakens, leaks down, or a chain guide breaks, slack can build up and let the belt or chain jump. Tensioner and idler failures are one reason belt kits usually include them. Our timing belt vs timing chain comparison covers what’s normally replaced at each service.

Installation errors

Valve timing is set whenever a belt or chain is replaced, so a mistake at that point is a common cause. Examples include misreading the timing marks, the crankshaft or camshaft moving during the job, not using the correct locking tools, or a sprocket bolt not tightened to specification so the sprocket slips later.

Variable valve timing faults

On engines with cam phasers, incorrect timing can come from the variable valve timing system itself: a sticking phaser, a faulty oil control solenoid, a clogged oil screen, or low or degraded oil. In these cases the belt or chain may be fine, but the camshaft isn’t where the computer wants it. See variable valve timing, CVVD and camless engines for how phasers work.

How mechanics confirm a valve timing problem

Typical diagnostic steps include:

  • Reading fault codes and live data: on modern engines, a scan tool can show actual vs desired cam position, which often points straight at a timing or phaser problem.
  • Checking the timing marks: with covers removed and the engine at the specified position, the marks on the crankshaft and camshaft sprockets should line up.
  • Compression and leak-down tests: low compression across all cylinders can indicate timing error; very low compression on one or more cylinders after a belt failure can indicate bent valves.
  • Scope or sensor analysis: comparing crankshaft and camshaft sensor signals can show whether cam timing has shifted without taking the engine apart.

What to do if you suspect it

  • Stop driving if the engine suddenly loses power, rattles loudly or stalls. Continuing can turn a repairable fault into major damage.
  • Don’t keep cranking an engine that stopped suddenly and won’t restart, especially if it’s an interference design. Each crank can push pistons into open valves.
  • Have it towed if a belt or chain failure is likely.
  • Don’t clear codes and carry on. Cam/crank correlation codes often reappear, and a stretching chain can get worse.

Can incorrect valve timing be fixed?

Usually, yes. If the engine hasn’t suffered internal damage, the fix is to correct the cause (replace the belt, chain, tensioner, guides or phaser as needed) and set the timing correctly. If valves have been bent, the cylinder head typically needs to come off for new valves and machine work, and pistons need inspecting. In the worst cases, replacing the engine can be more practical. A professional diagnosis, including a compression or leak-down test after the timing is corrected, is the best way to know where an individual engine stands.

The complete guide to timing and valvetrain

Engine Timing Explained: Ignition Timing, Valve Timing and Timing Wheels
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →