Engine Reliability

The Most Reliable Diesel Truck Engines: Cummins, Duramax and Power Stroke

The most reliable diesel truck engines by generation, from the 5.9 Cummins and 7.3 Power Stroke to the LBZ and L5P Duramax, plus the diesels to avoid.

On this page
  1. Why Older Diesels Have the Strongest Reputations
  2. Cummins (Dodge and Ram)
  3. Duramax (Chevrolet Silverado and GMC Sierra HD)
  4. Power Stroke (Ford Super Duty)
  5. Comparison Table
  6. Diesel Truck Engines to Avoid
  7. Is Diesel Always More Reliable Than Gas?
  8. How to Keep a Diesel Reliable

The diesel truck engines with the strongest reliability reputations are the 5.9-liter Cummins (especially the 1989–1998 12-valve and the 2003–2007 common-rail), the 7.3-liter Power Stroke (1994.5–2003), and the LBZ (2006–2007) and L5P (2017 onward) 6.6-liter Duramax. The modern 6.7-liter Power Stroke and 6.7-liter Cummins also have good records, though their emissions systems need more care.

The diesels with the worst reputations are the 6.0 and 6.4 Power Stroke, the first-generation Ram 3.0 EcoDiesel, and the LML Duramax because of its fuel pump. The details below are organized by brand and generation, so you can find the exact truck you’re looking at.

Why Older Diesels Have the Strongest Reputations

Many of the most respected diesel engines come from before about 2007, when US emissions rules for heavy-duty pickups got much tighter. Those older engines usually had:

  • Mechanical or simple electronic injection with no very-high-pressure pump to fail.
  • No diesel particulate filter (DPF), no selective catalytic reduction (SCR) and, on many, no exhaust gas recirculation (EGR). These systems added cost and failure points.
  • Heavy iron construction and modest power outputs, so the parts were lightly stressed.

Modern diesels make far more power, run cleaner and are quieter. Their core engines are often very strong. Most of their problems come from the emissions and fuel systems around the engine.

Cummins (Dodge and Ram)

5.9L 12-Valve (1989–1998)

The first- and second-generation Dodge Ram Cummins is the engine that made diesel pickups popular. It’s an inline-six derived from a commercial engine, with an iron block and head, gear-driven timing, two valves per cylinder and a fully mechanical injection pump (a Bosch VE rotary pump at first, then the Bosch P7100 inline pump from 1994). With almost no electronics, very little goes wrong.

Watch for: the “killer dowel pin” in the timing gear housing, which can work loose and drop into the gears. Fixing it is cheap preventive work. Mechanical lift pumps also wear out.

5.9L 24-Valve (1998.5–2002)

The 24-valve engine added four valves per cylinder and an electronically controlled Bosch VP44 rotary injection pump. The engine itself is robust, but the VP44 has a reputation for failing, often blamed on weak lift pumps starving it of fuel. Some blocks from this era (often called “53 blocks” after their casting number) can crack along the water jacket.

5.9L Common-Rail (2003–2007)

The 2003–2007 5.9 switched to high-pressure common-rail injection with the Bosch CP3 pump, which has an excellent reliability record. With no DPF or EGR on most versions, these trucks are often seen as a sweet spot: more modern and refined than the 12-valve, but still simple.

6.7L Cummins (2007.5 Onward)

The 6.7 brought more power, along with a DPF, EGR and, later, SCR with diesel exhaust fluid. The core engine is very strong. Most problems involve emissions components (EGR valves and coolers, DPF and sensors), especially on trucks that idle a lot or make lots of short trips.

Duramax (Chevrolet Silverado and GMC Sierra HD)

GM’s 6.6-liter Duramax V8, developed with Isuzu, has gone through several generations:

  • LB7 (2001–2004). A strong engine with a CP3 pump and no DPF. Its known weakness is cracking fuel injectors, which can dilute the oil with fuel. GM extended injector warranty coverage at the time. Many trucks have had replacement injectors.
  • LLY (2004.5–2005). Generally solid, but known for overheating when towing in hot weather.
  • LBZ (2006–2007). Often called the best Duramax. It has a strengthened block and internals, the CP3 pump and no DPF, and was paired with the six-speed Allison transmission from 2006.
  • LMM (2007.5–2010). The first Duramax with a DPF. The engine itself is strong, and most issues involve emissions parts.
  • LML (2011–2016). Strong engine, but it uses the Bosch CP4.2 high-pressure pump (see below). Many owners fit a pump conversion or protection kit.
  • L5P (2017 onward). Strengthened again and switched to a Denso HP4 pump. It has built a good reputation so far.

3.0L Duramax (Light-Duty)

GM’s 3.0-liter Duramax inline-six in the Silverado and Sierra 1500 (2020 onward) is efficient and generally well regarded. Its oil pump is driven by a belt that needs inspection and replacement on schedule, and early trucks have a specific service interval for it. Check whether the belt service has been done on higher-mileage trucks.

Power Stroke (Ford Super Duty)

  • 6.9L and 7.3L IDI (1983–1994). Built by International Harvester/Navistar, these indirect-injection engines are slow but simple and long-lived when they’re kept cool.
  • 7.3L Power Stroke (1994.5–2003). One of the most respected diesels ever built. It uses HEUI injection with iron construction and modest power. Typical minor issues are cam position sensors, glow plug relays and oil leaks.
  • 6.0L (2003–2007) and 6.4L (2008–2010). The two generations with the worst reputations. Head gaskets, EGR and oil coolers and fuel dilution are covered in our guide to Ford engines to avoid.
  • 6.7L Power Stroke (2011 onward). Ford’s in-house design. Early versions used the CP4.2 pump, and fuel system contamination can be costly. Overall it has earned a strong reputation and is widely seen as Ford’s redemption after the 6.0 and 6.4.

Comparison Table

Engine Years Reputation Key watch-out
Cummins 5.9 12-valve 1989–1998 Excellent Killer dowel pin, lift pump
Cummins 5.9 24-valve 1998.5–2002 Good VP44 pump, “53” block cracks
Cummins 5.9 common-rail 2003–2007 Excellent Injectors at high mileage
Cummins 6.7 2007.5 onward Good Emissions components
Duramax LB7 2001–2004 Good Injectors
Duramax LLY 2004.5–2005 Fair to good Overheating when towing
Duramax LBZ 2006–2007 Excellent Few widespread issues
Duramax LMM 2007.5–2010 Good DPF/emissions
Duramax LML 2011–2016 Fair CP4.2 pump failure
Duramax L5P 2017 onward Very good Emissions components
Power Stroke 7.3 1994.5–2003 Excellent Sensors, minor leaks
Power Stroke 6.0 2003–2007 Poor Head gaskets, EGR/oil cooler, FICM
Power Stroke 6.4 2008–2010 Poor Fuel dilution, coolers, radiator
Power Stroke 6.7 2011 onward Very good Fuel system on early CP4 trucks

Diesel Truck Engines to Avoid

  • Ford 6.0 and 6.4 Power Stroke, unless they come with documented repairs and upgrades.
  • Ram 3.0 EcoDiesel, first generation (2014–2019). This light-duty V6 had reports of crankshaft and connecting rod bearing failures, EGR cooler recalls and other emissions issues.
  • LML Duramax, unless the CP4.2 pump has been addressed. The CP4 family’s reputation comes largely from US ultra-low-sulfur diesel’s lower lubricity. When the pump wears internally, it can send metal debris through the entire fuel system, so the repair covers far more than the pump.
  • Oldsmobile 5.7 diesel (a car and light truck engine from 1978–1985). See the least reliable engines of all time.

Is Diesel Always More Reliable Than Gas?

Not always. Diesel engines are built with heavier parts to handle high compression, and they do much of their work at low rpm, which helps them last. But modern diesels have expensive fuel and emissions systems, and maintenance costs more. For trucks that rarely tow or mostly make short trips, a gas engine can be the more reliable and cheaper choice. That’s one reason many Ram buyers choose the HEMI. See our guide to Ram 5.7 HEMI problems for that side of the comparison.

How to Keep a Diesel Reliable

  • Change fuel filters on schedule and drain the water separator. Water and dirt are the enemies of high-pressure injection.
  • Use quality fuel from busy stations.
  • Change oil on time, especially on engines prone to fuel dilution.
  • Avoid long idling and short trips on DPF-equipped trucks, and let regenerations finish.
  • Use the correct DEF and keep it clean on SCR-equipped trucks.
  • Watch coolant condition. Diesel cooling systems, and their EGR coolers, depend on clean coolant.
  • Before buying used, have a diesel specialist scan the engine, check for blow-by and look for signs of emissions tampering, which can make a truck illegal to register in some areas.

The complete guide to engine reliability

The Least Reliable Engines of All Time
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →